Skip to main content

Where Do I Fit In?

Published June 22, 2026 by Josh Grimenstein

Behind every championship, conference title, and school record is a group of athletes working toward a common goal. Every sports team comes in its own shape and size, but every team is composed of talented individuals who are unique from one another. With such large, diverse teams comes the challenge of helping new athletes find a sense of belonging. One question almost every athlete asks at some point is, "Where do I fit in?" Especially in college athletics, it can be easy to compare yourself to team captains, top scorers, or veteran athletes and wonder what you contribute. However, college teams rely on more than just points and wins to be successful. Today, I want to talk about the character roles each athlete plays—roles that have nothing to do with positions, statistics, or playing time, but everything to do with helping a team succeed on and off the field.

First, I should clarify the difference between a character role and a position. A football quarterback and a soccer goalie are both examples of athletic positions; they help each player know where to be and what to do on the field. Outside of training and competition, these positions matter very little. Character roles affect a sports team every day, both in and out of practice. A positive teammate, hard worker, mentor, and motivator are all examples of character roles. These roles help keep team morale high and push athletes to become the best versions of themselves.

Let's return to the central question: "Where do I fit in?" Many athletes feel they need to pick a role to contribute to their team. In reality, the role you play should flow naturally from your personality. A positive teammate is not a narcissist off the field, a hard worker does not slack off when they get home, and a motivator will not whisper unkind things under their breath. The personality you bring to your team should reflect how you strive to act every day. Your strengths can also benefit your team. Think about the strengths you already possess—there is no need to change yourself to fit a specific role. Those strengths are already enough to make a difference.

That said, while you should never change yourself to fit a role that doesn't suit you, your role on a team can evolve. Maybe your personality changes, or the team's dynamic shifts and requires more from you. Imagine you are a positive, motivating teammate and your team has just gone through a difficult week of practice. Everyone, including you, is exhausted. In that situation, you may need to be even more uplifting than usual while not allowing your own struggles to bring you down. It is important to be flexible and willing to step outside your comfort zone to help your teammates. At the same time, you should not push yourself so far outside your comfort zone that you take on responsibilities you are not equipped for. Know your strengths, understand your mindset, and be aware of your limits.

I want to share my experience from my freshman year of swimming. Coming in, I knew I wasn't the fastest athlete on the team, but I believed that if I worked hard enough, I could drop significant time and become a standout contributor. I had high hopes of scoring at GLIACs and qualifying for Nationals; neither of those happened. As the season progressed, I began to understand that my value to the team was not determined by points alone. I have always tried to be friendly to the people around me and give my full effort in whatever I do. I noticed those out-of-the-pool qualities being displayed during training and leaving a positive impact on my teammates. My role on the team developed naturally. I try to support my teammates and motivate those around me to swim their best during both practice and competition. My role next season may look different, but only time will tell.

Now let's imagine a team without these character roles. After a difficult week of training or a tough loss, morale is low. Without an upbeat teammate, there may be nobody to lift everyone's spirits and get the team back on its feet. Or imagine a new class of freshmen arriving with nobody willing to mentor them. Those athletes may struggle to find their place and feel connected to the team. In both situations, athletes are likely performing below their potential. While it is possible to push forward on your own, the people around you influence you more than you may realize. Even the most understated roles can have a significant impact on team culture and performance.

So, where do you fit into your team? The answer is different for every athlete. Some athletes lead through their words, while others lead through their work ethic, positivity, or willingness to support those around them. No matter what role you play, your impact extends beyond points scored, races won, or records broken. Teams are built on the collective efforts of individuals who each bring something unique to the group. Whenever you find yourself comparing your accomplishments to those of your teammates, remember that success is not always measured on a scoreboard. Take time to recognize the strengths you already possess and consider how they can help those around you. Whether you are a leader, motivator, mentor, or source of positivity, your contribution matters.

You should never ask whether you belong on a team. Instead, ask how you can use your unique qualities to make that team stronger. When every athlete understands the value they bring and works together toward a common goal, the entire team succeeds.

 

Josh Grimenstein
Page last modified June 29, 2026