The Muskegon Lake Long-Term Monitoring Program began in 2003, in an effort to observe and document changes in the ecological health of Muskegon Lake and provide the data needed to remove Muskegon Lake from the list of Great Lakes Areas of Concern (AOC). As part of the program, the lake is sampled 3 times per year at 6 sites for a suite of biological, physical, and chemical parameters.

As a complement to the long-term monitoring program, the Muskegon Lake Observatory was established in 2011. The observatory consists of a buoy system that collects continuous water quality, hydrology, and meteorological data during the ice-free period.

Key water quality indicators were selected from these datasets to create a water quality dashboard for Muskegon Lake. The goal of the dashboard is to provide a visual representation of the current status and historical trends in Muskegon Lake water quality, by rating each indicator along a scale from desirable (green) to undesirable (red) conditions. Each scale also includes a category that indicates the water quality goal for the lake is being met (yellow).

We selected dashboard indicators that are commonly used to assess water quality and are relevant to AOC delisting: total phosphorus (TP), chlorophyll a, Secchi disk depth, and dissolved oxygen. Each indicator is described in more detail below.

COVID-19 restrictions prevented spring water quality sampling in early May 2020 and delayed the deployment of the Muskegon Lake Observatory Buoy until August 2020. In the past, we presented annual averages for the three seasons that we sample; since 2020, we have presented the dashboard as seasonal averages across sites to reveal the changes over time in the lake and provide greater detail on lake changes. When dashboard data are organized by season, the influence of spring data on annual means (as shown in prior dashboards) is revealed. For example, lower TP and chlorophyll a values in spring offset the larger TP values in summer and fall when averaged over the entire sampling season, which obscures the seasonal differences; conversely, the deeper Secchi disk values in spring (i.e., clearer water) counter the shallower summer and fall seasonal depths (i.e., more turbid water).

The 2022 data indicate that Muskegon Lake’s annual water quality means continue to approach goal thresholds, with annual means either being just outside of goal thresholds or meeting goals. It remains unclear if the COVID-19 pandemic had any influence on 2020 water quality data, as restrictions and changes in social behaviors may have limited recreational use in Muskegon Lake. While our long-term monitoring program provides useful information to evaluate lake water quality trends over time, the limited sampling effort (6 sites, 3×/yr) can miss important episodic events. For example, very intense harmful algal blooms formed in Muskegon Lake in fall 2021, which were not captured as part of the long-term monitoring work. The lake’s ecological health, while certainly improved from the industrial era (Steinman et al. 2008; Liu et al. 2018), still has room for improvement.

Target Concentration: 30 µg/L

Current Status

(2022)

Historical Status

(1972, 2003-2022)

As one of the key nutrients that fuels algal growth, phosphorus concentration can indicate the potential for a lake to sustain undesirable algal blooms. The phosphorus dashboard was created by calculating seasonal average TP concentrations measured in the surface water of the 6 long-term monitoring stations. Historical data collected by the US EPA (Freedman et al. 1979) are included as a reference point for historical conditions.

Spring TP continued its long-term trend remaining within the Desirable threshold, and although TP concentrations nearly doubled from Spring 2021, data are similar to past sampling years. Summer TP has been hovering near 30 µg/L since 2019 and slightly increased from 2021, now placing it in the Undesirable category. Likewise, a smaller increase was seen in Fall TP from 2021 and remains Undesirable. Overall in 2022, all three seasonal means and the annual mean TP (31±10 µg/L) have increased, resulting in an annual 2022 TP rating of Undesirable.

Data sources: Freedman et al. (1979); Muskegon Lake Long-term Monitoring Program, Steinman et al. (2008) and AWRI (unpublished data)

Target Concentration: 10 µg/L

Current Status

(2022)

Historical Status

(1972, 2003-2022)

Chlorophyll a is the green pigment found in photosynthetic algae. Measuring chlorophyll a is one way to estimate the amount of algal biomass present in lake water. The chlorophyll a dashboard was created by calculating annual average chlorophyll a concentrations measured in the surface water of the 6 long-term monitoring stations. Historical data collected by the US EPA (Freedman et al. 1979) are included as a reference point for historical conditions.

Spring TP continued its long-term trend remaining within the Desirable threshold, and although TP concentrations nearly doubled from Spring 2021, data are similar to past sampling years. Summer TP has been hovering near 30 µg/L since 2019 and slightly increased from 2021, now placing it in the Undesirable category. Likewise, a smaller increase was seen in Fall TP from 2021 and remains Undesirable. Overall in 2022, all three seasonal means and the annual mean TP (31±10 µg/L) have increased, resulting in an annual 2022 TP rating of Undesirable. 

Data sources: Freedman et al. (1979); Muskegon Lake Long-term Monitoring Program, Steinman et al. (2008) and AWRI (unpublished data)

Target Depth: 2.0 m

Current Status

(2022)

Historical Status

(1972, 2003-2022)

Secchi disk depth is an estimate of water clarity, measured using a standard black and white disk. Low water clarity can be the result of algal biomass, suspended particulate matter, or natural staining of the water. The Secchi depth dashboard was created by calculating annual average Secchi depths measured at the 6 long-term monitoring stations. Historical data collected by the US EPA (Freedman et al. 1979) are included as a reference point for historical conditions. Unlike TP and chlorophyll a, the larger (i.e., deeper) the Secchi depth number, the better the water quality. 

In 2022, the status for Secchi depth qualified as the Meeting Goal category for each season, representing slightly worsening spring water clarity and slightly improved fall clarity compared to 2021. Overall in 2022, the annual mean Secchi disk depth was 2.26 (±0.15) m.

Data sources: Freedman et al. (1979); Muskegon Lake Long-term Monitoring Program, Steinman et al. (2008) and AWRI (unpublished data)

2022 Mean % Days < 2 mg/L: 26%
Target Mean % Days < 2 mg/L: 25%

Data source: Muskegon Lake Observatory, B. Biddanda (unpublished data)

Well-oxygenated water is critical to the healthy functioning of aquatic ecosystems, including sustaining populations of fish and bottom-dwelling organisms, such as insects, worms, mollusks, and snails. In overly-productive (i.e., eutrophic) lakes, dissolved oxygen (DO) can become depleted in the bottom waters, particularly during summer months. The DO dashboard was created by calculating the percentage of time during the annual monitoring period (May-October) that the daily average DO was less than 2 mg/L in the bottom waters at the Muskegon Lake Observatory buoy.

Acknowledgements

We are very grateful to the many people associated with collecting the data on Muskegon Lake that help inform this dashboard, including Bopi Biddanda, Mike Hassett, Maggie Oudsema, Brian Scull, Terry Boerson, Tim Halloran, Eric Hecox, Emily Kindervater, Jasmine Mancuso, Rachel Orzechowski, James Rahe, Ian Stone, Autumn Taylor, and Sean Woznicki.

We also gratefully acknowledge the Community Foundation for Muskegon County and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) for helping to fund the monitoring efforts in Muskegon Lake.

References

Freedman, P., R. Canale, and M. Auer. 1979. The impact of wastewater diversion spray irrigation on water quality in Muskegon County lakes. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C. EPA 905/979006-A.

Liu, B., McClean, C.E., Long, D.T., Steinman, A.D., and R.J. Stevenson. 2018. Lake eutrophication and recovery over a 200-year period of post-native American settlement was determined by a complex set of local and regional factors. Science of the Total Environment 628-629: 1352-1361.

Steinman, A.D., M. Ogdahl, R. Rediske, C.R. Ruetz III, B.A. Biddanda, and L. Nemeth. 2008. Current status and trends in Muskegon Lake, Michigan. Journal of Great Lakes Research 34: 169-188.